Should Miami Ohio Be Higher in the AP Top 25 Poll?

Segment Spotlight: Quick Hits From The Craig Carton Show

Miami of Ohio's Unprecedented Undefeated Season and Ranking Challenges

In an intriguing discussion on the Craig Carton Show, the spotlight shone on Miami of Ohio's basketball team, the sole undefeated team in Division 1A, boasting a remarkable 28-0 record. Despite this impeccable performance, their debut in the top 25 rankings only occurred recently, placing 25th in one poll and 21st in another. This late recognition raises questions about the impact of strength of schedule on the rankings and potential NCAA tournament qualifications.

The team's dominance in their conference, despite playing teams like Ohio, Toledo, and Western Michigan, showcases their consistency and skill. Yet, this has not translated into a higher ranking, primarily due to perceptions about their strength of schedule. The possibility looms that even if they maintain an undefeated record through the regular season but falter in the conference tournament, they could finish with a 33-1 record and still miss the NCAA tournament.

The conversation also touched on how Miami of Ohio, compared to basketball powerhouses such as Arizona, Duke, and Michigan, is undervalued and should not be ranked behind teams with multiple losses. Their situation draws comparisons with historically strategic teams that played fundamental basketball focused on maximizing each play, reminiscent of tactics employed by teams like those coached by Pete Carroll at Princeton, known for their deliberate and smart play style.

This segment from the Craig Carton Show sheds light on the intricate dynamics of college basketball rankings and the challenges faced by teams from smaller conferences, despite undefeated seasons.