Should You Trade Mahomes in Dynasty Fantasy Football?

Dynasty Fantasy Football: Should You Trade Patrick Mahomes?

In the ongoing debate within fantasy football circles, particularly in dynasty leagues regarding whether it's advantageous to trade Patrick Mahomes, opinions are sharply divided. Dynasty owners might be pondering if now is the opportune moment to trade away a potentially high-value player like Mahomes, but the consensus is that the timing might not be right.

The primary concern is that trading Mahomes now could mean selling low. As Mahomes is currently the third-best fantasy quarterback this season, his high ranking underscores his continuing value on the field, despite the Chiefs' challenges. However, the potential uncertainty surrounding the team's future — including whether Coach Andy Reid will remain with the team, the possible restructuring of the offensive line, and the acquisition of a consistent running back — could impact Mahomes' future performance.

The argument against trading Mahomes hinges on the difficulty of getting fair value in return right now. Many teams in one-quarterback dynasty leagues may not be desperate enough at the quarterback position to offer an equal or greater value trade. The unpredictability of the Chiefs' offensive support in upcoming seasons adds to the risk. If Kansas City can secure more significant assets like they did in the past with stars such as Corey Dillon and Randy Moss for Tom Brady, the scenario could change. For now, unless a dynasty owner is presented with an irresistibly favorable deal, the suggestion is to hold onto Mahomes.

On the other hand, some argue for trading Mahomes on the premise that the Chiefs need to make significant additions to their offense. They point out that Kansas City needs a high-caliber player comparable to Ja'Marr Chase or Justin Jefferson to secure Mahomes' success in the coming years. The concern is that without substantive enhancements to the skill positions and a reliance on less proven players, Mahomes' peak years could be jeopardized, potentially making this the optimal time to trade him for maximum future value.

Ultimately, whether to trade Mahomes in a dynasty format depends on the specific circumstances of each fantasy team owner, including their team's competitive timeline, their read of the Chiefs' future moves, and the offers on the table. While some might find it prudent to buy into the idea of trading Mahomes now, the safer recommendation appears to be to sell this idea, recommending holding onto him unless an exceptional deal is presented.