NFL · 5 hours ago

Colin Cowherd’s Push for Steelers to trade T.J. Watt

Bo Marchionte

Host · Writer

Steelers: Stacked at Outside Linebacker
The Quarterback Angle Nobody Wants to Discuss

This is where the conversation becomes uncomfortable.

The Steelers invested draft capital in both Will Howard and Drew Allar, but neither player should prevent the organization from pursuing a franchise quarterback if the right opportunity presents itself in 2027.

Mike McCarthy's entire coaching legacy is tied to quarterback development. From Aaron Rodgers to Dak Prescott, his greatest successes have come with signal callers he believed could lead a championship-caliber offense.

If Pittsburgh enters the 2027 NFL Draft armed with multiple first-round selections or additional premium picks, the franchise suddenly gains flexibility.

Flexibility creates options.

Options create opportunity.

Trading Alex Highsmith would likely bring meaningful draft compensation.

Trading T.J. Watt could potentially produce a massive haul that reshapes the future of the organization.

Nobody inside the building is giving up on Howard or Allar.

If McCarthy identifies a quarterback he believes can become the next face of the franchise, additional draft ammunition could allow Pittsburgh to move aggressively up the board.

That's the hidden layer beneath every trade discussion.

It may not be about replacing Watt or Highsmith.

It may be about positioning the Steelers to find the next Ben Roethlisberger.

Steelers Quick Hits
- Howard and Allar remain developmental investments.
- Neither should prevent Pittsburgh from pursuing an elite quarterback prospect.
- Mike McCarthy's track record is closely tied to quarterback development.
- Additional 2027 draft capital creates flexibility to move up the board.
- A blockbuster trade today could be about finding tomorrow's franchise quarterback.
Steelers: Stacked at Outside Linebacker
Omar Khan Never Stops Turning Over Stones

The Pittsburgh Steelers have long been associated with stability. For decades, roster building often resembled a slow burn rather than a fireworks display. That perception changed when Omar Khan took control.

Since becoming general manager, Khan has operated with a sense of urgency. He has traded up, traded down, acquired veterans, moved on from familiar faces and shown little hesitation when an opportunity presents itself.

The modern NFL rewards aggressive decision makers, and Khan has embraced that reality.

As Organized Team Activities conclude and the Steelers inch closer toward training camp, a fascinating question lingers beneath the surface.

Could Pittsburgh be preparing for another major move?

The timing of Nick Herbig's extension, Alex Highsmith's absence from practice and the ongoing contract discussion surrounding T.J. Watt have naturally fueled conversation.

Perhaps it's all coincidence.

Perhaps it isn't.

Colin Cowherd mentioned the scenario after the Cleveland Browns moved on from Myles Garrett in blockbuster trade with Los Angeles Rams.

Five Things to Think About
- Omar Khan has reshaped the roster aggressively since taking over.
- Pittsburgh has become far more active in the trade market.
- The Steelers have invested heavily in younger core players.
- Major contracts often create difficult roster decisions.
- The pass-rush room suddenly has everyone's attention.
Steelers: Stacked at Outside Linebacker
Nick Herbig's Rise Changes Everything

Nick Herbig didn't merely earn an extension.

He forced Pittsburgh's hand. The predicted forecast for his open market price in 2027 surely forced the Steelers hand to sign the talented and young pass rusher to a lucrative contract extension.

The young outside linebacker emerged as one of the defense's most productive playmakers and eventually led the Steelers in sacks last season. His relentless motor, versatility and ability to finish around the quarterback made him impossible to ignore.

The organization rewarded him accordingly.

When teams commit significant resources to a player, they aren't simply paying for past production. They're investing in future expectations.

That's where the conversation becomes interesting.

Herbig's extension secures one edge position for years to come. It also raises questions about how the Steelers intend to allocate future resources across a room that includes both Alex Highsmith and T.J. Watt.

The Steelers now possess three starting-caliber edge defenders.

History suggests keeping all three long-term becomes increasingly difficult.

Herbig Quick Hits
- Herbig led Pittsburgh in sacks last season.
- The Steelers committed massive money to keep him.
- Edge rusher remains one of football's premium positions.
- Financial realities eventually force tough decisions.
- Herbig's deal immediately created speculation about the future.
Steelers: Stacked at Outside Linebacker
The Highsmith Absence Will Be Watched Closely

Coincidence or simply illness?

That's the question surrounding Alex Highsmith's absence following Nick Herbig's blockbuster extension.

The Steelers officially stated Highsmith missed practice because of sickness. By all accounts, he remained at the facility and there has been no indication of a holdout or dispute.

Still, timing matters.

In today's NFL, every absence is scrutinized. Every missed practice generates theories. Every unexplained development becomes a headline.

If Highsmith is absent again when media members observe Tuesday's OTA session, speculation will only intensify heading into training camp.

That doesn't mean a trade is coming.

It does mean people will begin asking the question louder.

And in Pittsburgh, where Khan has established a reputation for making bold moves, those questions carry more weight than they once did.

Highsmith Quick Hits
- Highsmith's absence was officially listed as illness.
- The Steelers have indicated no contract dispute exists.
- Timing immediately sparked discussion.
- Another absence would increase outside speculation.
- Khan's aggressive history keeps trade scenarios alive.
Steelers: Stacked at Outside Linebacker
The Unthinkable Scenario of Trading T.J. Watt

There are certain players fans assume will never wear another uniform.

T.J. Watt belongs on that list.

He is the face of the defense, a former Defensive Player of the Year and one of the greatest pass rushers in franchise history.

Which is exactly why the conversation refuses to disappear.

Elite players carry elite value.

If negotiations become complicated and another franchise offers a historic package of draft capital, every general manager must at least listen.

That doesn't mean Pittsburgh wants to move Watt.

Far from it.

But NFL history is littered with trades nobody believed possible until they happened.

The Steelers are attempting to build a roster capable of sustained success. Sometimes that means making decisions that are unpopular in the short term for the sake of the future.

The idea of Watt being traded remains unlikely.

Yet it is no longer impossible to imagine.

Watt Quick Hits
- Watt remains one of the NFL's premier defenders.
- Franchise icons have been traded before.
- His market value would be enormous.
- Contract dynamics always influence decisions.
- An unlikely scenario is still a scenario.
Steelers: Stacked at Outside Linebacker
Why Philadelphia Makes Too Much Sense

If a blockbuster were ever to materialize, one destination immediately jumps to the front of the line.

Philadelphia.

No general manager has been more willing to chase elite pass rushers than Howie Roseman.

The Eagles have consistently built their roster around dominating the line of scrimmage. They draft defensive linemen, sign defensive linemen and trade for defensive linemen.

It's part of their identity.

Both Alex Highsmith and T.J. Watt fit the exact mold Philadelphia covets productive, battle-tested pass rushers capable of changing games with a single snap.

Roseman has never been afraid of a headline-grabbing transaction.

Neither has Khan.

That's what makes the connection intriguing.

Again, there is no evidence a trade is imminent.

But when one aggressive general manager possesses a surplus at a premium position and another is constantly searching for pass-rush help, the possibility becomes difficult to completely dismiss.

Roseman Quick Hits
- Howie Roseman has a history of blockbuster trades.
- Philadelphia prioritizes pass rushers above almost everything.
- The Eagles constantly invest in the trenches.
- Highsmith and Watt fit their defensive philosophy.
- Two aggressive GMs always create interesting possibilities.
Steelers: Stacked at Outside Linebacker
The Quarterback Angle Nobody Wants to Discuss

This is where the conversation becomes uncomfortable.

The Steelers invested draft capital in both Will Howard and Drew Allar, but neither player should prevent the organization from pursuing a franchise quarterback if the right opportunity presents itself in 2027.

Mike McCarthy's entire coaching legacy is tied to quarterback development. From Aaron Rodgers to Dak Prescott, his greatest successes have come with signal callers he believed could lead a championship-caliber offense.

If Pittsburgh enters the 2027 NFL Draft armed with multiple first-round selections or additional premium picks, the franchise suddenly gains flexibility.

Flexibility creates options.

Options create opportunity.

Trading Alex Highsmith would likely bring meaningful draft compensation.

Trading T.J. Watt could potentially produce a massive haul that reshapes the future of the organization.

Nobody inside the building is giving up on Howard or Allar.

If McCarthy identifies a quarterback he believes can become the next face of the franchise, additional draft ammunition could allow Pittsburgh to move aggressively up the board.

That's the hidden layer beneath every trade discussion.

It may not be about replacing Watt or Highsmith.

It may be about positioning the Steelers to find the next Ben Roethlisberger.

Steelers Quick Hits
- Howard and Allar remain developmental investments.
- Neither should prevent Pittsburgh from pursuing an elite quarterback prospect.
- Mike McCarthy's track record is closely tied to quarterback development.
- Additional 2027 draft capital creates flexibility to move up the board.
- A blockbuster trade today could be about finding tomorrow's franchise quarterback.
Steelers: Stacked at Outside Linebacker
Omar Khan Never Stops Turning Over Stones

The Pittsburgh Steelers have long been associated with stability. For decades, roster building often resembled a slow burn rather than a fireworks display. That perception changed when Omar Khan took control.

Since becoming general manager, Khan has operated with a sense of urgency. He has traded up, traded down, acquired veterans, moved on from familiar faces and shown little hesitation when an opportunity presents itself.

The modern NFL rewards aggressive decision makers, and Khan has embraced that reality.

As Organized Team Activities conclude and the Steelers inch closer toward training camp, a fascinating question lingers beneath the surface.

Could Pittsburgh be preparing for another major move?

The timing of Nick Herbig's extension, Alex Highsmith's absence from practice and the ongoing contract discussion surrounding T.J. Watt have naturally fueled conversation.

Perhaps it's all coincidence.

Perhaps it isn't.

Colin Cowherd mentioned the scenario after the Cleveland Browns moved on from Myles Garrett in blockbuster trade with Los Angeles Rams.

Five Things to Think About
- Omar Khan has reshaped the roster aggressively since taking over.
- Pittsburgh has become far more active in the trade market.
- The Steelers have invested heavily in younger core players.
- Major contracts often create difficult roster decisions.
- The pass-rush room suddenly has everyone's attention.

Jun 8 6:35 PM

SpreadMoneyTotal

SEA

-1.5

-120

O 9

BAL

+1.5

+102

U 9

Jun 8 6:40 PM

SpreadMoneyTotal

NYY

+1.5

+110

O 7.5

CLE

-1.5

-130

U 7.5

EDITOR'S PICKS

NFL Depth Charts

2026 NFL Draft Hub

NFL Free Agency 2026

app_store

For the Best of SportsGrid, Grab the App

BETTING NEWS

Casino · 1 month ago

3 Benefits to Online High Limit Slots

Casino · 1 month ago

Popular Entertainment Themes You Can Play on Casinos Online

Casino · 1 month ago

7 Popular Casino Themes That Recently Debuted Online

Casino · 1 month ago

Online Casinos Begin to Offer Free Spin Choices

Casino · 1 month ago

Are the Online Versions of Slots I've Seen in Casinos the Same?

FUTURES

MLB · 1 day ago

MLB Futures: Mariners, Yankees, and More Division Predictions

MLB · 1 day ago

MLB Futures: Ohtani, Acuna, and Sanchez Battle for Awards

MLB · 1 day ago

MLB Futures: Top Cy Young Contenders and Betting Insights

MLB · 3 days ago

Analyzing the Fierce National League Cy Young Race

MLB · 3 days ago

Aaron Judge Injury Shakes Up Latest 2026 AL MVP Race