College Football Playoff Committee Faces SEC Bias Claims
Dan Sileo
Host · Writer

Segment Spotlight: Quick Hits From Outspoken With Dan Sileo
College Football Committee’s Selection Process Lacks a Clear Metric
The College Football Committee has made a mess of the situation this year, particularly this week. This may be the worst selection committee since the format was introduced. It is unclear what direction the committee is taking or what metric it is using.
Indiana dropped five spots without playing, while teams such as Alabama moved up. There appears to be SEC bias, and that criticism is coming from an SEC guy. There are not many great teams in either the Big Ten or the SEC, so how does the committee differentiate between teams with similar records? Is it based on the name on the jersey or the logo on the helmet?
The committee has not provided a clear metric for selecting and ranking the 12 teams. Its members also appear stubborn in how they approach the process each week. The central question should be simple: Which teams are truly the best in the country? Does anyone really believe UCLA is one of the five best teams in the country? Absolutely not.
Based on the current bracket, Georgia, Alabama, Utah, Miami and Notre Dame have the best opportunities to win the national championship. The remaining teams could be placed in almost any order. Only a handful of teams have shown that they have a legitimate chance.
The selection process has also become heavily influenced by television. Why is a committee needed to help choose a national champion? No other sport in North America relies on a committee in this way. Championships should be decided on the field.
In the past, sportswriters selected national champions following the major bowl games. At least those teams had played, and voters could consider schedules and common opponents. Georgia may still win the national championship and be a deserving champion. In fact, Georgia appears to be ahead of everyone else.
However, any team can lose in a single 60-minute game. The University of Miami once beat Nebraska 31-30 and was upset by Penn State in another season. That unpredictability is part of the beauty of college football.
College football loses some of its appeal during bowl season when selection committees place teams into games. The process has become a network-driven and political vehicle for Disney and ESPN, which now have considerable influence over college football.
Is the committee truly selecting the best 12 teams for the playoff? Its decisions this year have demonstrated a bias toward the Southeastern Conference. The SEC may be better than the Big Ten this year, but when two teams with 6-3 records have not played common opponents, there is no definitive way to know which one is better. The committee is only guessing.
College football needs a system built around common opponents rather than committee selections. The current approach to choosing the teams that will compete for the national championship is not working.
If Georgia wins the national championship, some people will claim that the committee got it right. That would miss the point. Georgia is the best and most complete team in the country, as well as the best-coached team. The Auburn loss was terrible, but Alabama also has a strong resume when considering its strength of schedule, the teams it has played and the teams that have beaten it.
Alabama may deserve to be ranked third in the playoff. The larger issue is the need for a better metric and an end to committee-driven selections. College football should decide its championship on the field again.
BETTING NEWS
FUTURES




