NCAAF · 6 hours ago

10 Most Overrated Teams in College Football Right Now: Going Into Week 6

Grant White

Host · Writer

10. North Carolina Tar Heels
North Carolina Tar Heels Team Profile
- Head Coach: Bill Belichick (2nd Season)
- Offensive Coordinator: Bobby Petrino
- Defensive Coordinator: Steve Belichick
- Conference: ACC
- Location: Chapel Hill, North Carolina
- AP Top 25 Ranking: NR
- 2026 Record: 2-2
A few teams were in contention for the last spot on our list. Western Kentucky deserves some heat. UConn's wheels are falling off. West Virginia has been exposed. Still, it's time to put some pressure on Bill Belichick and the North Carolina Tar Heels.

Since taking over, Belichick and UNC have gone 6-10, with a dismal 2-7 record in ACC play. Sure, they held their own versus Notre Dame on Saturday, but this is still a team that can't find a way to move the football. The Tar Heels rank 108th in total offense, propped up by an unflattering win over East Tennessee in Week 2.

The Bill Belichick experiment isn't working. The North Carolina Tar Heels will have a tough time against Pitt. That sentiment carries into every future game on their schedule.
1. USC Trojans
USC Trojans Team Profile
- Head Coach: Lincoln Riley (4th Season)
- Offensive Coordinator: Luke Huard
- Defensive Coordinator: Gary Patterson
- Conference: Big Ten
- Location: Los Angeles, California
- Stadium: Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
- AP Top 25 Ranking: No. 19
- 2026 Record: 5-1
The USC Trojans accomplished two things in Week 5. First, they improved their record to 5-1 with a win over Washington. More notably, they ascended our chart as the most overrated team in college football.

The Trojans were expected to win comfortably. Instead, USC was down at the half and needed a defensive touchdown to take the lead eventually.

USC struggled to move the ball against Washington at home, and we have no idea how they'll put up yards at Penn State this weekend.

It's been a good run, but this team is about to fall out of the Top 25.
2. SMU Mustangs
SMU Team Profile
- Head Coach: Rhett Lashlee (5th Season)
- Co-Offensive Coordinators: Rob Likens, Garin Justice, D’Eric King
- Co-Defensive Coordinators: Maurice Crum Jr., Rickey Hunley Jr.
- Conference: ACC
- Location: University Park, Texas
- AP Top 25 Ranking: No. 24
- 2026 Record: 4-1
The SMU Mustangs continue to get way too much credit for their early-season performances.

To recap, SMU has beaten UC-Davis, Missouri State, Boston College, and FSU. Even against that ragtag group of teams, they've looked unimpressive.

It's impossible to reconcile how this team is still ranked. A winnable schedule only propels this team higher in the standings, but they definitely don't deserve to be there.
3. Florida Gators
Florida Gators Team Profile
- Head Coach: Jon Sumrall (1st Season)
- Offensive Coordinator: Buster Faulkner
- Defensive Coordinator: Brad White
- Conference: SEC
- Location: Gainesville, Florida
- AP Top 25 Ranking: 16
- 2026 Record: 4-1
The Florida Gators took us all on a bit of a ride. Initially, we were skeptical about their long-term chances. Then, foolishly, we gave them the benefit of the doubt. But after Week 5's thrashing at Mizzou, our initial concerns were validated.

The Gators are nothing without their offense. They were stymied by Missouri in Week 4, and the Tigers have looked beatable early this season. Facing some of the premier defenses in the country in the SEC, we should see this team falter over the coming weeks.

With games at Texas and at Georgia coming up, Florida stands to lose all of the ground it made up early this season.
4. Mississippi State Bulldogs
Mississippi State Bulldogs Team Profile
- Head Coach: Jeff Lebby (2nd Season)
- Offensive Coordinator: N/A
- Defensive Coordinator: Zach Arnett
- Location: Starkville, Mississippi
- AP Top 25 Ranking: 17
- 2026 Record: 4-1
No one expected the Mississippi State Bulldogs to be ranked at any point this season, so maybe they don't belong on this list. But after Week 4's good old-fashioned ass-whooping by Alabama, maybe it's time to call them out.

Mississippi State's immaculate four-week run came to a screeching halt. The Bulldogs' defense had no answer for Bama's methodical attack, and their offense couldn't keep pace. In the end, the Crimson Tide exposed the Bulldogs for who they really are.

Mississippi State dropped one spot in the Top 25 rankings. Formerly 16th-ranked and now sitting 17th, the Bulldogs should be getting way more heat than they are.
5. Iowa Hawkeyes
Iowa Hawkeyes Team Profile
- Head Coach: Kirk Ferentz (27th Season)
- Offensive Coordinator: Tim Lester
- Defensive Coordinator: Phil Parker
- Location: Iowa City, Iowa
- Stadium: Kinnick Stadium
- AP Top 25 Ranking: No. 20
- 2026 Record: 4-1
The Iowa Hawkeyes are the Big Ten's Mississippi State Bulldogs. No one expected them to beat Ohio State in Week 5, but the Hawkeyes really floundered and proved they still have a long way to go before they can be taken seriously.

Iowa failed on both sides of the football. The 484 yards they gave up on defense were close to double the 238 they mustered. And with less than 22 minutes of possession time, the Hawkeyes didn't have an effective game plan to compete.

It's time to get real about the Hawkeyes. If they somehow manage to run the table and sneak into the Big Ten Championship Game, they could be the least deserving participant in conference history. We think it's more likely they'll lose two of their next four.
6. Michigan Wolverines
Michigan Wolverines Team Profile
- Head Coach: Kyle Whittingham (1st Season)
- Offensive Coordinator: Jason Beck
- Defensive Coordinator: Jay Hill
- Conference: Big Ten
- Location: Ann Arbor, Michigan
- Stadium: Michigan Stadium
- AP Top 25 Ranking: NR
- 2026 Record: 3-2
Ah, the Michigan Wolverines; arguably, college football's most overrated team. Thankfully, the voters thought better of including the Wolverines in their rankings. For some reason, some of the public thinks this is still a competent team. Let us assure you that's patently false.

Michigan dropped another conference showdown, bested by the Minnesota Golden Gophers in Week 5. In that one-sided affair, the Wolverines put up 180 yards of total offense while holding the ball for just 22:24.

Heading into a bye week to lick their wounds, the Wolverines emerge with back-to-back games versus Penn State and then at Indiana. That's without considering their future encounters versus Oregon, UCLA, and Ohio State.

Michigan's only goal is bowl eligibility, and that may still overstate their chances.
7. Louisville Cardinals
Louisville Cardinals Team Profile
- Head Coach: Jeff Brohm (4th Year)
- Offensive Coordinator: Brian Brohm
- Defensive Coordinator: Mark Ivey, Steve Ellis
- Conference: ACC
- Location: Louisville, Kentucky
- Stadium: L&N Federal Credit Union Stadium
- AP Top 25 Ranking: No. 16
- 2026 Record: 2-3
People need to stop romanticizing the Louisville Cardinals. This program is a shell of its former self, and it keeps getting beaten by middle-of-the-road college football teams.

Most recently, the Cardinals were humbled by a one-dimensional NC State squad. The Wolfpack sit in the bottom half of the country defensively, and Louisville was still out-gained and out-possessed by a substantive margin.

Now sitting with a losing record and no defensive integrity, Louisville is headed towards a disappointing season.
8. Ole Miss Rebels
Ole Miss Rebels Team Profile
- Head Coach: Pete Golding (1st Season)
- Offensive Coordinator: John David Baker
- Defensive Coordinator: Bryan Brown
- Conference: SEC
- Location: Oxford, Mississippi
- AP Top 25 Ranking: No. 9
- 2026 Record: 3-1
It may have been a bye week for the Ole Miss Rebels, but we haven't lost sight of them as an overrated team.

The Rebels got an undeserved week off after Week 4's laughable defeat versus Florida. That loss looks even worse following the Gators' implosion versus Mizzou. Still, Ole Miss is clinging to a spot in the Top 10 and is expected to win big at Vandy in Week 6.

Even with an extra week to prepare, we're skeptical of the Rebels' chances in Nashville. We wouldn't be surprised if the Rebels are handed their second loss of the season on Saturday.
9. Auburn Tigers
Auburn Team Profile
- Head Coach: Alex Golesh (1st Season)
- Offensive Coordinator: Joel Gordon
- Defensive Coordinator: DJ Durkin
- Conference: SEC
- Location: Auburn, Alabama
- AP Top 25 Ranking: NR
- 2026 Record: 3-2
Another week, another uninspired loss by the Auburn Tigers. This time, Auburn was outmatched by the Tennessee Volunteers, and the Tigers might have just two winnable games left on their schedule.

Auburn's offense remains one of the worst in the conference. If we negate the 610 they put up against 1-3 Southern Miss, the Tigers are averaging just 347.8 yards per game. More concerningly, only one of their games has come against a Top 50 defense in the country. Surely, that's enough to convince people that this offense can't be taken seriously.

Auburn closes out the month with games versus Georgia, LSU, and Ole Miss. And the Tigers don't have a chance in any of those.
10. North Carolina Tar Heels
North Carolina Tar Heels Team Profile
- Head Coach: Bill Belichick (2nd Season)
- Offensive Coordinator: Bobby Petrino
- Defensive Coordinator: Steve Belichick
- Conference: ACC
- Location: Chapel Hill, North Carolina
- AP Top 25 Ranking: NR
- 2026 Record: 2-2
A few teams were in contention for the last spot on our list. Western Kentucky deserves some heat. UConn's wheels are falling off. West Virginia has been exposed. Still, it's time to put some pressure on Bill Belichick and the North Carolina Tar Heels.

Since taking over, Belichick and UNC have gone 6-10, with a dismal 2-7 record in ACC play. Sure, they held their own versus Notre Dame on Saturday, but this is still a team that can't find a way to move the football. The Tar Heels rank 108th in total offense, propped up by an unflattering win over East Tennessee in Week 2.

The Bill Belichick experiment isn't working. The North Carolina Tar Heels will have a tough time against Pitt. That sentiment carries into every future game on their schedule.
1. USC Trojans
USC Trojans Team Profile
- Head Coach: Lincoln Riley (4th Season)
- Offensive Coordinator: Luke Huard
- Defensive Coordinator: Gary Patterson
- Conference: Big Ten
- Location: Los Angeles, California
- Stadium: Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
- AP Top 25 Ranking: No. 19
- 2026 Record: 5-1
The USC Trojans accomplished two things in Week 5. First, they improved their record to 5-1 with a win over Washington. More notably, they ascended our chart as the most overrated team in college football.

The Trojans were expected to win comfortably. Instead, USC was down at the half and needed a defensive touchdown to take the lead eventually.

USC struggled to move the ball against Washington at home, and we have no idea how they'll put up yards at Penn State this weekend.

It's been a good run, but this team is about to fall out of the Top 25.